Re: HCB + Flickr + DeleteMe! Publikumsvoting = Kulturrevolution!
Geizhals » Forum » Foto & Video » HCB + Flickr + DeleteMe! Publikumsvoting = Kulturrevolution! (8 Beiträge, 149 Mal gelesen) Top-100 | Fresh-100
Du bist nicht angemeldet. [ Login/Registrieren ]
.
Re: HCB + Flickr + DeleteMe! Publikumsvoting = Kulturrevolution!
16.06.2009, 00:44:28
Den Kommentar dazu find ich gut:

André Rabelo, I want to point out that you're not the first "clever" person to add one of the master's photos here. In fact, Chalkstar used to add HCB photos as well. Just to play devil's advocate though, what was a masterpiece 20 years ago might be considered shite today. Quality and art is (and is rightfully so) judged through the lens of time. If "Citizen Kane" came to the theatres today it wouldnt be nearly as special a film as it is - because it would have no new ground to break -- nothing new to offer. Likewise, if you were to duplicate this shot exactly today, it would likely never get published or considered to be a good (much less great) shot. Thats just the way it is - its been done, redone and improved since the time HCB did it. That said, I think this group often excludes great shots merely because of some minor nitpick. A perfect photo doesnt need to be technically perfect. It doesn't *need* to be - but it should help.


Ich bin zwar trotzdem der Meinung, das das betroffene Foto grossartig ist, aber recht hat er schon auch. Je abhängiger eine Kunstform von der Technik ist, desto vergänglicher ist sie... sag ich jetzt mal.
------------------------------------------------------
Some people never go crazy.
What truly horrible lives they must lead.
-Charles Bukowski-

---
letztes Update...10.05.09 http://ungutknut.at
Antworten PM Alle Chronologisch Zum Vorgänger
 
Melden nicht möglich
 

Dieses Forum ist eine frei zugängliche Diskussionsplattform.
Der Betreiber übernimmt keine Verantwortung für den Inhalt der Beiträge und behält sich das Recht vor, Beiträge mit rechtswidrigem oder anstößigem Inhalt zu löschen.
Datenschutzerklärung